Travel Guide To Eleuthera: Top Restaurants and Bars in Eleuthera
Eleuthera’s beaches are world-class and the island vibes are so chill that you won’t ever want to leave. The Eleuthera restaurants, hotels and bars are low-key and inviting, but are considered more expensive despite being in a developing country. Being on an island, access to products, produces and meats are much tougher which causes the influx in prices. I suggest storing some groceries in your accommodation but enjoying a few meals out as all of these Eleuthera Restaurants listed have it’s own unique charm and are waterfront. Here’s a rundown of the top restaurants and bars in Eleuthera, in The Bahamas.
It’s crucial to note when discussing things to eat in Eleuthera, that every Friday night, Fish Frys are the most popular pastime. It’s an incredibly popular, weekly occurrence throughout all of The Bahamas Islands. Be sure to check which restaurants are serving so that you can partake! Or if you’re lucky, you’ll be invited into someone’s home! Locals and Restaurants fry up the fresh catch of the week in various ways: BBQ’d, battered and fried. Fish Frys bring families, communities and tourists together. And almost always, it turns into a party (yes, the Bahamians love a good time!). Music playing, lots of alcohol consumption, friends and families gather to dance the night away.
Have A Taste of Conch
Conch (pronounced as ‘conk’) is the national food of the Bahamas. This clam-like creature is native to the Atlantic Ocean. You can try conch in different forms such as salads, conch ceviche, and conch fritters in restaurants and small stands on the island.
Read my article about the best conch salad in Nassau here.
Where to Watch Sunset in Eleuthera:
- French Leave Resort (mid-Eleuthera in Governor’s Island)
- Frigate’s (Rock Sound Beach) – Do bring bug spray!
Where to Eat in Eleuthera: Restaurants
Da Perk Cafe
- Coffee Shop
- Coffee, Beverage, Sandwiches, Dessert, Salads, Vegan-friendly
- Breakfast, Lunch
- Opening Hours: Mon-Sat 8:00am-4:00pm
- Queen’s Highway, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-2620
Da Perk Cafe is located at the heart of Governor’s Harbour and is popular among tourists and locals. The cafe serves coffee, tea, and other beverages as well as breakfast and lunch. If you are dying to get your coffee fix while you are on the island, make sure to drop by and have a cup of joe!
Tippy’s Restaurant & Beach Bar at Pineapple Fields Resort
- Casual Dining, Bar
- Seafood, American, Bahamian, Caribbean
- Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: 12:00nn-9:30pm | Closed on Mondays
- Banks Road, Pineapple Fields Resort, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-3331
Tippy’s Restaurant & Beach Bar is located in the Pineapple Fields Resort in Eleuthera. This beachfront restaurant is known for its conch fritters and the relaxing ambiance. Food is served fresh and the service is top-notch. It is recommended you call for a reservation in advance.
1648 – An Island Restaurant at French Leave Resort
- Casual Dining
- Seafood, American, Bahamian, Caribbean, Vegan-friendly, Gluten-free options
- Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: Sun-Thu 7:00am-10:00pm | Fri-Sat 7:00am-11:00pm
- Queen’s Highway, French Leave Resort, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-3778
1648 – An Island Restaurant at French Leave Resort is an indoor/outdoor restaurant that serves both local and international cuisines. This restaurant was rated 4.5 out of 5 by TripAdvisor travelers. This is a great spot to enjoy a meal while watching the sun go down.
Buccaneer Club
- Casual Dining, Bar & Grill
- Seafood, Caribbean, Bahamian, Vegan-friendly, Gluten-free options
- Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: 7:00am-9:00pm | Happy Hour Tue-Sun 4:00pm-6:00pm
- Haynes Avenue, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-2000
Buccaneer Club is known for its amazing breakfast menu and a wide variety of dishes to choose from for lunch and dinner. TripAdvisor travelers highly recommend the Bahamian Mac & Cheese and their conch fritters.
Bacchus Fine Food & Wine
- Casual Dining, Cafe, Deli
- Seafood, Organic Food, Mediterranean, Greek, Vegetarian-friendly
- Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: Mon-Tue, Fri 9:00am-6:00pm | Wed 9:00am-9:00pm | Sat-Sun 9:00am-4:00pm
- Banks Road, North of Pineapple Fields Resort, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 470-6563
Bacchus Fine Food & Wine is a gourmet deli located in Governor’s Harbour. This restaurant serves healthy and organic gourmet meals. Get Italian cheese and bread at the deli for your picnic trip to the beach before heading out.
Daddy Joe’s Restaurant & Bar
- Casual Dining, Bar
- Seafood, Bahamian, Vegan-friendly
- Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: 11:00am-10:00pm | Closed Mondays
- Gregory Town, Queen’s Highway, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 335-5688
Daddy Joe’s Restaurant & Bar is located just a mile away south of the Glass Window Bridge. The restaurant serves authentic Bahamian cuisine and is known for its conch wrap.
Pammy’s Restaurant & Takeaway
- Casual Dining, Takeaway
- Snack, Bahamian
- Breakfast, Lunch
- Opening Hours: 7:30am-10:30am / 11:00am-5:00pm
- Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-2843
Pammy’s Restaurant & Takeaway is a go-to restaurant for the locals as the restaurant serves mostly native dishes at an affordable price. Pammy’s is popular for its conch burger and grouper burger. The restaurant doesn’t look much from the outside and the seats are very limited. But don’t let that hold you back; most people prefer to just order takeaways.
The Front Porch
- Casual Dining
- Seafood, Bahamian, Vegan-friendly, Gluten-free options
- Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: 12:00nn-3:00pm / 5:00pm-9:00pm
- Hatchet Bay, Queen’s Highway, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 335-0727
The Front Porch is a restaurant overlooking the Hatchet Bay. The restaurant serves a wide variety of native dishes. Try out their lobster and crab claws or pick whatever is the fresh catch of the day. This restaurant requires a reservation.
Governor’s Harbour Bakery
- Bakery, Takeaway
- Bahamian, Bread & Pastries, Beverage
- Breakfast, Lunch
- Opening Hours: Mon-Fri 7:00am-5:00pm / Sat 7:00am-2:00pm
- Tucker Lane, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-2071
Although not a restaurant, Governor’s Harbour Bakery is something you should not miss during your trip in Eleuthera. Enjoy freshly baked Bahamian bread and pastries or grab a hearty sandwich for lunch. Make sure you try the cinnamon swirls and pineapple tartlets!
Sammy’s Place
- Casual Dining
- Seafood, Bahamian, American, Vegetarian-friendly
- Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner
- Opening Hours: 7:30am-9:00pm
- Albury Avenue, Rock Sound, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 334-2121
If you are taking a trip to Lighthouse Beach, I suggest you ask the locals to point you to Sammy’s Place. This place is popular for their conch dishes and the staff is friendly. TripAdvisor travelers gave this restaurant a 4.5.
Top Bars in Eleuthera
Watering Holes in Eleuthera: Where to Drink
The local beer are Sands Beer, Pirate Republi and Kalik. Rum is a popular liquor as it is in all of the Caribbean.
One simply doesn’t go to Eleuthera for the night life or partying. It’s an incredibly sleepy island for the honeymooners or families looking for quality, relaxing time. But there is no shortage of beers and booze at at every Eleuthera restaurants you visit! There are a few bars open throughout the island, but most will likely close by midnight. I would ask a local what’s open on what specific days, depending on season. You may have better luck going to some of the very local spots not catered to tourists if you want to find a bar open later.
Frigate’s Bar & Grill
- Bar, Casual Dining
- Beer, Cocktails, Caribbean, Seafood, Bahamian, American, Vegan-friendly
- Opening Hours: 12:00nn-9:00pm
- Rock Sound 1, Block South of The Marketplace, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 470-1777
Frigate’s Bar and Grill is the it-spot in Rock Sound and has a great menu of drinks and cocktails if you want to relax and have drinks after a long day at the beach. This bar and grill is rated 5 out of 5 by TripAdvisor travelers. Also a great place for sunset and a swim on their private beach. Though be sure to pack on bug spray!
Fishbone Beach Bar & Grill
- Bar, Casual Dining
- Beer, Cocktails, Caribbean, Seafood, Bahamian, Vegan-friendly
- Opening Hours: Sun 10:00am-7:00pm | Mon-Sat 10:00am-9:00pm
- Savannah Sound, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 836-7550
Nothing beats a cold beer, some freshly caught fish and conch fritters in between sightseeing and beach trips. Fishbone Beach Bar and Grill is popular among tourists and locals alike among the Eleuthera Restaurants circuit for the great menu and affordability. Laid back surfer vibes with interior that’s like a beach hut as well as outdoor dining. Fishbone also sits on it’s own beach where you can lounge and swim. There are live music on some evenings.
Sunset Lounge
- Bar, Casual Dining
- Beer, Cocktails, Caribbean, Bahamian, Vegetarian-friendly
- Opening Hours: Mon-Fri 11:00am-10:00pm | Sat-Sun 12:00am-10:00pm
- Gregory Town, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 699-5598
Sunset Lounge is a restaurant and bar located in Gregory Town. This place is popular for get-togethers and music nights. If you wish to meet more locals and other travelers, this is the spot at night for a drink and to enjoy some Bahamian music.
Ronnie’s Island Hi-D-Way
- Pub
- Beer, Cocktails
- Opening Hours: Open 24 hours
- Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-2307
Ronnie’s Island Hi-D-Way is one of the oldest establishments in Eleuthera. This pub has been a favorite hangout place for both locals and tourists. If you want a quick drink or you want to hear more about the locals’ life on the island, this place is a must-visit.
Dilly Tree
- Sports Bar
- Beer, Cocktails
- North Palmetto Point, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 332-1510
Dilly Tree is a sports bar located in North Palmetto Point. If you are looking for a good bar scene and a good hangout place to meet people, Dilly Tree is the perfect spot in the area. Grab a drink and enjoy game nights at the Dilly Tree.
The Deck
- Bar, Casual Dining
- Beer, Cocktails, Caribbean, Bahamian
- Opening Hours: Fri-Wed 11:00am-7:00pm | Closed on Thursdays
- Knowles Drive, Governor’s Harbour, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 535-8283
The Deck is a lowkey seaside grill and bar located in Governor’s Harbour. This is a great place to have a drink while enjoying the sunset.
The Shipyard Restaurant and Bar
- Bar, Casual Dining
- Beer, Cocktails, Caribbean, Seafood, Bahamian, Vegan-friendly
- Opening Hours: Wed-Mon 11:30am-10:00pm
- Spanish Wells, Eleuthera
- +1 (242) 333-5010
The Shipyard Restaurant and Bar is a waterfront restaurant bar located in the Spanish Wells. This restaurant is a TripAdvisor’s Certificate of Excellence 2015-2019 winner. The Shipyard has a bar on the second floor that has an amazing view of the sea.
Though it’s considered “North Eleuthera”, Spanish Wells is its own separate island. To get there, it’s a 7 minute taxi ride and a 1 mile boat ride from North Eleuthera Airport to St. George’s Cay. Great place to go for the day.
For an Ultimate Eleuthera Travel Guide, visit https://www.bohemianvagabond.com/eleuthera-travel-guide.